For people with ADHD, medication can reduce the risk of accidents, crime and suicide

Source: The Conversation – Global Perspectives – By Adam Guastella, Professor and Clinical Psychologist, Michael Crouch Chair in Child and Youth Mental Health, University of Sydney

Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a neurodevelopmental condition that affects around 7% of children and 2.5% of adults.

ADHD causes difficulties holding and sustaining attention over periods of time. People with ADHD also experience hyperactivity and high levels of impulsiveness and arousal. This can make it difficult to plan, coordinate and remain engaged in tasks.

ADHD is linked to problems at work, school and home, and to higher rates of mental illnesses such as anxiety. It’s also associated with higher rates of long-term harms.

Stimulant medication, such as methylphenidate and dexamphetamine, is the most common treatment for managing ADHD symptoms. Most people with ADHD will respond to at least one ADHD medication.

But, rising rates of prescriptions in recent years has prompted concern for their effectiveness and safety.

New research published today in the journal BMJ points to additional longer-term benefits. It found people with ADHD who took medication were less likely to have suicidal behaviours, transport accidents, issues with substance misuse, or be convicted of a crime.

What did the study do?

The study tracked 148,581 people who received a new diagnosis of ADHD between 2007 and 2018.

The authors used population-based data from Swedish national registers, including everyone aged six to 64 who was newly diagnosed with ADHD. The average age was 17.4 years and 41% were female.

Participants either started or did not start medication within three months of their ADHD diagnosis.

The authors examined the effects of drug treatment for ADHD on five critical outcomes: suicidal behaviours, substance misuse, accidental injuries, transport accidents and committing crime. They looked at both first-time and recurrent events.

This study used a method that uses data from health records or registries to mimic the design of a randomised controlled trial, in an attempt to reduce bias.

The researchers accounted for age, education, other mental and physical illnesses, prior history and use of other drugs, to account for factors that may influence results.

What did they find?

Within three months of receiving an ADHD diagnosis, 84,282 (56.7%) of people had started drug treatment for ADHD. Methylphenidate was the most commonly prescribed drug, accounting for 88.4% of prescriptions.

Drug treatment for ADHD was associated with reduced rates of a first occurrence for four out of the five outcomes: a 17% reduction for suicidal behaviours, 15% for substance misuse, 12% for transport accidents and 13% for committing crime.

When the researchers looked at people with recurrent events, the rate reductions associated with ADHD medication were seen for all five outcomes (including accidental injury).

The effect of medication was particularly strong when someone had a history of these events happening frequently. This means those with the most severe symptoms may benefit most.

Stimulant drugs were associated with lower rates of all five outcomes compared with non-stimulant drugs.

It’s likely these benefits are associated with improvements in attention, impulsivity and hyperactivity. People may be less likely to be distracted while driving, to self-medicate and show impacts from other mental health challenges.

What didn’t the study do?

The large sample size, use of national linked registers and sophisticated design give greater confidence that these findings are due to medication use and not due to other factors.

But the study was not able to examine medication dosages or track whether people reliably took their medication as prescribed. It also had no way to track the severity of ADHD symptoms. This means it can’t tell us if this helped most people or just some people with severe symptoms.

We know that ADHD medication helps most people, but it is not effective for everyone. So, we still need to understand why some people don’t benefit from ADHD medication, and what other treatments might also be helpful.

Finally, even though the study was rigorous in its design and adjusted for many factors, we can’t rule out that other unaccounted factors could be associated with these effects.

As prescribing increases, the size of the benefit decreases

A second study, published in June, used the same Swedish national registers and self-controlled case series design.

This study also concluded ADHD medication was associated with reduced risks for self-harm, accidental injuries, transport accidents and committing crime.

However, this study also showed that as prescribing rates increased nearly five-fold between years 2006 to 2020, the size of the observed benefits of ADHD medications reduced.

While remaining significant, the size of the associations between ADHD medication use and lower risks of unintentional injury, traffic crashes, and crime weakened over this time.

This could mean people who are less likely to need ADHD medications are now receiving them.

What are the impacts for patients and policymakers?

People need to know that if ADHD medications are helpful for them or their children, it might also improve many other areas of life.

These findings can also give governments confidence that their recent initiatives and efforts to increase access to ADHD support and treatment may have positive downstream impacts on broader social outcomes.

But medications aren’t the only ADHD treatment. Medication should only represent one part of a solution, with other psychological supports for managing emotional regulation, executive and organisational skills and problem-solving also beneficial.

Psychological therapies are effective and can be used in combination with, or separately to, medication.

Yet research shows drug treatments are relied on more frequently in more disadvantaged communities where it’s harder to access psychological supports.

Policymakers need to ensure medication does not become the only treatment people have access to. People with suspected ADHD need a high-quality diagnostic assessment to ensure they get the right diagnosis and the treatment most suitable for them.

The Conversation

Adam Guastella receives independent research funding from research organisations (e.g., MRFF, NHMRC, ARC) to investigate the effecicy of supports for children and adults with neurodevelopmental conditions. He is employed as the Michael Crouch Chair in Child and Youth Mental Health at the University of Sydney.

Kelsie Boulton receives funding from research organisations (MRFF) to evaluate the efficacy of interventions for neurodevelopmental conditions.

ref. For people with ADHD, medication can reduce the risk of accidents, crime and suicide – https://theconversation.com/for-people-with-adhd-medication-can-reduce-the-risk-of-accidents-crime-and-suicide-263044

At 50, The Rocky Horror Picture Show is ‘imperfectly’ good (and queer) as ever

Source: The Conversation – Global Perspectives – By Craig Martin, Lecturer in Screen Studies, Swinburne University of Technology

Stanley Bielecki Movie Collection/Getty Images

For half a century, The Rocky Horror Picture Show has lured costumed fans to cinemas for late-night screenings. Its raunchy mix of Broadway musical, science fiction and schlock horror was originally a box-office flop. However, after its first midnight screening on April Fool’s Day 1976 at the Waverly theatre in New York, it never left the late-night circuit and became the ultimate cult film.

Tim Curry’s powerhouse performance as Frank-N-Furter is central to the film’s success. Yet, his truly astounding work often overshadows the film’s many other dynamic performances.

Rocky Horror’s supporting characters and chorus feature alluring oddballs who irreverently challenge norms of physical desirability. Their “imperfect” bodies are not only a tribute to diversity: they radically upturn genre expectations of stage and screen musicals, and discredit broader cultural ideals of beauty.

It’s so dreamy, oh fantasy free me!

Brad Majors (Barry Bostwick) and Janet Weiss (Susan Sarandon) are an attractive young couple seeking help at an isolated castle when their car blows a tyre. During their night, they find the castle’s inhabitants are of a variety of sizes, physiques and galaxies.

Adapted from Richard O’Brien’s 1973 stage musical, Rocky Horror’s anti-Broadway aesthetic is apparent as soon as the “butler” Riff Raff (O’Brien) opens the castle door. This wiry framed hunchback with tangled hair is a far cry from the athletic ideal of the Broadway body.

Inside the creepy mansion, we are dazzled by a festive troupe of alien “Transylvanians” wearing off-beat tuxedos and textured waistcoats. It’s a broad assortment of unconventional body types squeezed into colourful costumes.

Lanky actor Stephen Calcutt stands at 198 centimetres tall, and Sadie Corré at just over 120cm. Hugh Cecil, then 62, has alopecia, which exaggerates his stark monocled whiteness. Fran Fullenwider, with her wild, teased-out coiffure and curvy frame, is clad in skin-tight pants.

Cecil and Fullenwider were among a handful of Transylvanians director Jim Sharman recruited from London-based Ugly Models. While this agency’s name and viability is, to say the least, unfortunate, Rocky Horror’s rejection of cookie-cutter casting was celebratory, not diminishing.

The Transylvanians’ subversion of “sameness” is especially powerful because of the history of its film genre. Busby Berkeley, one of film musicals’ founding innovators in the 1930s and 1940s, is famously quoted as approving the “girls” in his ensembles as being “matched, just like pearls”.

Inverting such sexist tropes, the crass collective of Transylvanians is widely adored as the chorus of the film’s legendary song, Time Warp. They are also welcomingly representative of the throngs of fans who the film has continued to assemble these past five decades.

I can make you a man

Once Frank-N-Furter has invited everyone “up to the lab”, we encounter two more vital characters: the dichotomous Eddie and Rocky.

Gregarious rocker Meat Loaf’s Eddie refuses the lean hypersexual image typical of frontmen in 1970s rock acts. Eddie motorbikes around Frank’s lab and delights his sweetheart Columbia (Nell Campbell). He is loud, sexy and very nearly loved.

Overtly parodying Frankenstein’s creation of a grotesque monster, Frank-N-Furter scientifically “births” the perfectly chiselled Rocky (Peter Hinwood).

With Rocky, Frank-N-Furter has made a “perfect specimen of manhood”: muscular, a sharp jawline, blonde hair and a tan. But Rocky does not have Eddie’s charismatic body positivity, which Frank-N-Furter resents.

Rocky’s blonde hair and sculpted physique bears more than a passing resemblance to Jack Wrangler or Casey Donovan, superstars in the “Golden Age of Porn” of 1969 to 1984.

Wrangler was a pioneering porn star who adopted a rugged Marlborough Man aesthetic. Not unlike Frank-N-Furter, Wrangler was sexually fluid, working in gay porn for ten years from 1970 before crossing over to straight porn.

Donovan found fame in Wakefield Poole’s successful X-rated film Boys in the Sand (1971). Both Donovan and Poole were newcomers to filmmaking and porn. Poole (himself a Broadway dancer) applied a dreamlike narrative and an artistically verité shooting style to his hardcore yet poetic pornography.

On its release, Boys in the Sand was reviewed in Variety, and ads for the film appeared in the New York Times. Poole’s film achieved an enviable level of critical legitimacy and public appeal, which evaded Rocky Horror until it gained legitimacy via its enduring cult status.

Rocky Horror’s presentation of the creature as a queer ideal of masculine physical perfection spicily mirrors the coveted masculine form on display in much gay pornography.

Yet, among Rocky Horror’s eclectic cast, Rocky’s musclebound physique is positioned as very much the exception.

Don’t dream it, be it

Unlike gay icon Wrangler, the blonde Adonis Rocky figure is not a rugged hero, but the monster: an aberration whose existence is the result of “mad science”.

In this reading, the alluring but destructive Frank-N-Furter represents western society’s beauty machine, intent on artificially creating bodies designed to be looked at as objects of sexual desire, queer or straight.

The Rocky Horror Picture Show US poster art.
LMPC via Getty Images

This insight is far from outdated. Indeed, since 1975, Rocky’s queer-inflected bodily “perfection” has today become a problematic norm in the mainstreaming of men’s body sculpting and the proliferation of homoerotic imagery marketed to men.

However, Rocky Horror remains a place where people of all shapes, sizes, ages, abilities, and colours can dance and sing and celebrate without such constraints. In fact, Riff Raff, the “imperfect” figure who first welcomes us to the castle, ultimately kills Frank-N-Furter and halts his exploitation.

Rocky Horror offers many and varied midnight-movie audiences freedom from society’s troubling and relentless obsession with body image, even 50 years on.

The Conversation

The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

ref. At 50, The Rocky Horror Picture Show is ‘imperfectly’ good (and queer) as ever – https://theconversation.com/at-50-the-rocky-horror-picture-show-is-imperfectly-good-and-queer-as-ever-261852

The hidden costs of cancer for young survivors is derailing their financial futures

Source: The Conversation – Canada – By Giancarlo Di Giuseppe, PhD Candidate, Division of Epidemiology, Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto

Imagine being 25, fresh out of post-secondary education and full of optimism about starting your career, and then you hear the words: “You have cancer.”

You are suddenly faced with an unexpected health shock that not only threatens your physical health, but also your financial future. Most of your time is now spent feeling unwell and travelling to and from the hospital for treatment, while your friends and colleagues continue to build their careers.

This is the reality for nearly 1.2 million adolescents and young adults diagnosed with cancer each year worldwide, a number that is projected to rise. Just over 9,000 Canadian adolescents and young adults are diagnosed with cancer annually, and 85 per cent of them will survive their illness.

And while survival is the primary goal, many don’t realize that it comes with a hidden price that extends far beyond immediate medical costs.

It is estimated that the average Canadian affected by cancer faces $33,000 in lifetime costs related to their illness, totalling $7.5 billion each year for patients and their families.

But we have recently discovered the true economic impact on adolescents and young adults with cancer is often far greater than the previous numbers show and lasts much longer than previously recognized.

The financial penalty of survival

We compared 93,325 Canadian adolescents and young adults diagnosed with cancer and 765,240 similar individuals who did not experience cancer, and found that surviving cancer leads to long-term reduced income, which may last a lifetime.

On average, a cancer diagnosis results in a greater than five per cent reduction in earnings over a 10-year period after diagnosis.

As expected, income loss is more pronounced right after diagnosis, with survivors earning 10 to 15 per cent less in the first five years.

However, these hidden survival costs are not the same for everyone, and the financial toll varies greatly depending on the type of cancer. For instance, survivors of brain cancer see their average annual income drop by more than 25 per cent. This is a devastating financial burden — and one that endures.

The true lifetime effects are unknown, but it is not difficult to imagine how a financial setback like this can completely derail a young person’s financial future.

Why cancer costs young survivors more

Adolescents and young adults who are survivors of cancer experience “financial toxicity,” which refers to the direct costs of cancer, such as treatment or medication costs, and indirect costs like reduced work ability, extended sick leave and job loss.

Over one-third of young cancer patients report financial toxicity.

Many cancer survivors experience lasting adverse physical and cognitive effects that limit everyday functioning.

Even in the Canadian universal health-care system, which does not require payment for cancer treatment, many younger Canadians are unable to work and need to rely on family members for financial support.

The impact on work capacity is significant for adolescents and young adults who are just beginning their careers, causing them to miss critical years of career development during treatment and recovery that can have cascading economic effects.

These challenges can ultimately lead to financial instability and hardship.

Paying the price

Beyond the individual hardships, the issue of financial instability among young cancer survivors is becoming a broader societal challenge.

In 2025, young Canadian cancer survivors are entering an economy with an unfavourable job market and rising youth unemployment, as well as a widening gap between wages and housing affordability.
Rising inflation and general unaffordability are also compounding financial difficulties young Canadian cancer survivors face, ultimately making financial recovery more challenging.

Income is a fundamental social determinant of health, and financial inequities can perpetuate health disparities in cancer survivors after treatment.

Patients are forced into making devastating financial choices like depleting their savings and incurring debt.

Policy

A Canadian Cancer Society 2024 report highlights the urgency for support systems to address financial well-being after cancer.

Based on our research, which assesses the financial life of adolescent and young adult survivors of cancer, we have some recommendations for Canadian policymakers, businesses and primary care providers.

Policymakers should:

  • Make employment insurance benefits that better support survivors post-treatment.
  • Provide tax credits for groups of cancer survivors disproportionately affected by financial toxicity, such as those with brain cancer.

Primary care providers should:

  • Incorporate financial navigation counselling into their cancer care.
  • Provide resources for navigating insurance and financial assistance programs.
  • Routinely screen for financial toxicity as part of survivorship care.

Employers should:

Young cancer survivors have already faced one of life’s most difficult challenges. They shouldn’t have to struggle with financial insecurity.

By recognizing that survivorship starts at cancer diagnosis, we must broaden the conversation about cancer care beyond the clinical to the economic.

The Conversation

Jason D. Pole does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointments.

Giancarlo Di Giuseppe does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

ref. The hidden costs of cancer for young survivors is derailing their financial futures – https://theconversation.com/the-hidden-costs-of-cancer-for-young-survivors-is-derailing-their-financial-futures-256420

Glacial lake flood hits Juneau, Alaska, reflecting a growing risk as mountain glaciers melt around the world

Source: The Conversation – USA (2) – By Alton C. Byers, Faculty Research Scientist, Institute of Arctic and Alpine Research, University of Colorado Boulder

U.S. Geological Survey staff check monitoring equipment in Suicide Basin in June 2025. By August, the basin had filled with meltwater. Jeff Conaway/U.S. Geological Survey

Each summer in the mountains above Juneau, Alaska, meltwater from the massive Mendenhall Glacier flows into mountain lakes and into the Mendenhall River, which runs through town.

Since 2011, scientists and local officials have kept a close eye on one lake in particular: Suicide Basin, an ice-dammed bowl on an arm of the glacier. The glacier once covered this area, but as the ice retreated in recent decades, it left behind a large, deep depression.

In the summers of 2023 and 2024, meltwater filled Suicide Basin, overflowed its rim and escaped through tunnels in the ice, sending surges of water downstream that flooded neighborhoods along the river.

On Aug. 12-13, 2025, Suicide Basin flooded again.

The surge of water from Suicide Basin reached record levels at Mendenhall Lake on Aug. 13 on its way toward Juneau. Officials urged some neighborhoods to evacuate. As the water rose, new emergency flood barriers appeared to have limited the damage.

The glacial flood risks that Juneau is now experiencing each summer are becoming a growing problem in communities around the world. As an Earth scientist and a mountain geographer, we study the impact that ice loss can have on the stability of the surrounding mountain slopes and glacial lakes, and we see several reasons for increasing concern.

Two photo shows the same scene 125 years apart. The glacier loss is evident, and the lake between Suicide Glacier and Mendenhall Glacier didn't exist in 1983
Two photo shows the same scene 125 years apart. The glacier loss is evident, and the lake between Suicide Glacier and Mendenhall Glacier didn’t exist in 1893.
NOAA/Alaska Climate Adaptation Science Center

The growing risk of glacial floods

In many mountain ranges, glaciers are melting as global temperatures rise. Europe’s Alps and Pyrenees lost 40% of their glacier volume from 2000 to 2023.

These and other icy regions have provided freshwater for people living downstream for centuries – almost 2 billion people rely on glaciers today. But as glaciers melt faster, they also pose potentially lethal risks.

Water from the melting ice often drains into depressions once occupied by the glacier, creating large lakes. Many of these expanding lakes are held in place by precarious ice dams or rock moraines deposited by the glacier over centuries.

A glacial lake with high peaks behind it shows how dams build up from the glacier's movement
Imja Lake, a glacial lake in the Mount Everest region of Nepal, began as meltwater ponds in 1962 and now contains 90 million cubic meters of water. Its water level was lowered to protect downstream communities.
Alton Byers

Too much water behind these dams or a landslide or large ice discharge into the lake can break the dam, sending huge volumes of water and debris sweeping down the mountain valleys, wiping out everything in the way.

The Mendenhall Glacier floods, where glacial ice holds back the water, are classic jökulhlaup, or “glacier leap” floods, first described in Iceland and now characteristic of Alaska and other northern latitude regions.

Erupting ice dams and landslides

Most glacial lakes began forming over a century ago as a result of warming trends since the 1860s, but their abundance and rates of growth have risen rapidly since the 1960s.

Many people living in the Himalayas, Andes, Alps, Rocky Mountains, Iceland and Alaska have experienced glacial lake outburst floods of one type or another.

A glacial lake outburst flood in the Sikkim Himalayas in October 2023 damaged more than 30 bridges and destroyed a 200-foot-high (60 meters) hydropower plant. Residents had little warning. By the time the disaster was over, more than 50 people had died.

Scientists investigate flooding from Mendenhall Glacier’s Suicide Basin.

Avalanches, rockfalls and slope failures can also trigger glacial lake outburst floods.

These are growing more common as frozen ground known as permafrost thaws, robbing mountain landscapes of the cryospheric glue that formerly held them together. These slides can create massive waves when they plummet into a lake. The waves can then rupture the ice dam or moraine, unleashing a flood of water, sediment and debris.

That dangerous mix can rush downstream at speeds of 20-60 mph (30-100 kph), destroying homes and anything else in its path.

The casualties of such an event can be staggering. In 1941, a huge wave caused by a snow and ice avalanche that fell into Laguna Palcacocha, a glacial lake in the Peruvian Andes, overtopped the moraine dam that had contained the lake for decades. The resulting flood destroyed one-third of the downstream city of Huaraz and killed between 1,800 and 5,000 people.

A satellite view of a large glacial lake at the edge of a deep valley.
Teardrop-shaped Lake Palcacocha, shown in this satellite view, has expanded in recent decades. The city of Huaraz, Peru, is just down the valley to the right of the lake.
Google Earth, data from Airbus Data SIO, NOAA, U.S. Navy, NGA, GEBCO

In the years since, the danger there has only increased. Laguna Palcacocha has grown to more than 14 times its size in 1941. At the same time, the population of Huaraz has risen to over 120,000 inhabitants. A glacial lake outburst flood today could threaten the lives of an estimated 35,000 people living in the water’s path.

Governments have responded to this widespread and growing threat by developing early warning systems and programs to identify potentially dangerous glacial lakes. In Juneau, the U.S. Geological Survey starts monitoring Suicide Basin closely when it begins to fill.

Some governments have taken steps to lower water levels in the lakes or built flood-diversion structures, such as walls of rock-filled wire cages, known as gabions, that divert floodwaters from villages, infrastructure or agricultural fields.

Where the risks can’t be managed, communities have been encouraged to use zoning that prohibits building in flood-prone areas. Public education has helped build awareness of the flood risk, but the disasters continue.

Flooding from inside and thawing permafrost

The dramatic nature of glacial lake outburst floods captures headlines, but those aren’t the only risks.

Englacial conduit floods originate inside of glaciers, commonly on steep slopes. Meltwater can collect inside massive systems of ice caves, or conduits. A sudden surge of water from one cave to another, perhaps triggered by the rapid drainage of a surface pond, can set off a chain reaction that bursts out of the ice as a full-fledged flood.

An englacial conduit flood begins in the Himalayas. Elizabeth Byers.

Thawing mountain permafrost can also trigger floods. This permanently frozen mass of rock, ice and soil has been a fixture at altitudes above 19,685 feet (6,000 meters) for millennia.

As permafrost thaws, even solid rock becomes less stable and is more prone to breaking, while ice and debris are more likely to become detached and turn into destructive and dangerous debris flows. Thawing permafrost has been increasingly implicated in glacial lake outburst floods because of these new sources of potential triggers.

A glacial outburst flood in Barun Valley started when nearly one-third of the face of Saldim Peak in Nepal fell onto Langmale Glacier and slid into a lake. The top image shows the mountain in 2016. The lower shows the same view in 2017.
Elizabeth Byers (2016), Alton Byers (2017)

How mountain regions can reduce the risk

A study published in 2024 counted more than 110,000 glacial lakes around the world and determined 10 million people’s lives and homes are at risk from glacial lake outburst floods.

To help prepare and protect communities, our research points to some key lessons:

  1. Some of the most effective early warning systems have proven to be cellphone alerts. If combined with apps showing real-time water levels at a dangerous glacial lake, residents could more easily assess the danger.

  2. Projects to lower glacier lakes aren’t always effective. In the past, at least two glacial lakes in the Himalayas have been lowered by about 10 feet (3 meters) when studies indicated that closer to 65 feet (20 meters) was needed. In some cases, draining small, emerging lakes before they develop could be more cost effective than waiting until a large and dangerous lake threatens downstream communities.

  3. People living in remote mountain regions threatened by glacial lakes need a reliable source of information that can provide regular updates with monitoring technology.

  4. Recently it has become clear that even tiny glacial lakes can be dangerous given the right combination of cascading events. These need to be included in any list of potentially dangerous glacial lakes to warn communities downstream.

The U.N. declared 2025 the International Year of Glaciers’ Preservation and 2025-2034 the decade of action in cryospheric sciences. Scientists on several continents will be working to understand the risks and find ways to help communities respond to and mitigate the dangers.

This is an update to an article originally published March 19, 2025, to include the latest Alaska flooding.

The Conversation

Suzanne OConnell receives funding from The National Science Foundation

Alton C. Byers does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

ref. Glacial lake flood hits Juneau, Alaska, reflecting a growing risk as mountain glaciers melt around the world – https://theconversation.com/glacial-lake-flood-hits-juneau-alaska-reflecting-a-growing-risk-as-mountain-glaciers-melt-around-the-world-263109

How Shakespeare can help us overcome loneliness in the digital age

Source: The Conversation – Canada – By Marie Trotter, PhD Candidate, Department of English, McGill University

Are you addicted to endless scrolling? Trapped by the algorithms on your smartphone? Theatre might just be the antidote.

“Denmark’s a prison,” says Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, in one of Shakespeare’s most famous dramas. In this scene, he is speaking to his friends Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, who have been recruited to spy on him by his mother and uncle.

Hamlet isn’t literally imprisoned, but he does feel trapped by his circumstances. He comes to realize that his uncle murdered his father, married his mother and then seized the kingship. He is being watched. He wants to escape the surveillance of the Danish court.

More than 400 years after Hamlet’s first performance, experts have warned that we are trapped and manipulated by the surveillance of our smartphones. Our online behaviour has transformed us into marketable data, and addictive algorithms have bound us to an endless recycling of what we have “liked.”

Digital tribalism threatens democracy

This digital herding also affects who we interact with online. We often find ourselves gathering with others who like the same people and share the same politics, seeking both protection and alleviation from loneliness.

This new form of digital entrapment has given birth to a kind of tribalism — a strong sense of loyalty to a group or community — that political and social researchers warn may threaten a foundational practice of democracy: the possibility of authentic conversation among people.

The technologies of surveillance have drastically changed since Shakespeare’s time. Today, our habits are transformed into data by a virtual panopticon of devices.

The loneliness that many of us, especially young people, are suffering echoes Hamlet’s sense of isolation and inability to voice his true feelings.

While our culture is very different from Shakespeare’s London, his plays — and those by others — still have the potential to bring people together and help us think deeply about our shared experience.

Shakespeare’s playhouse conversations

In Hamlet, the prince knows something is rotten in Denmark, but he finds that he cannot speak publicly about it. All alone on stage, he says: “But break, my heart, for I must hold my tongue.”

Today, it seems, he could just as easily be speaking about how we curate ourselves online in our unquenchable desire to be seen and heard by others. But it doesn’t have to be this way.

Consider Shakespeare’s playhouse, an extraordinary gathering place for thousands of people. It was a space where all kinds of people could have conversations with the actors and each other about all kinds of themes, like the justice of “taming” an unruly woman (The Taming of the Shrew), how to push back against the power of a tyrant (Richard III) or how Christians might think differently about Jews (The Merchant of Venice).

Shakespeare opened established ways of thinking to questioning, inviting audiences to see the world and each other in new ways.

And audiences in Shakespeare’s time didn’t just sit quietly and listen. They interacted actively and loudly with the actors and the stories they saw on stage.

Historical research suggests theatre helped change early modern society by making it possible for commoners to have a public voice. In this way, Shakespeare contributed to the emergence of modern democratic culture.

Conversation pieces

Hamlet is one of Shakespeare’s most frequently performed tragedies, and his anguish under a surveillance state speaks to our own struggles for freedom and belonging.

In his soliloquies, he questions his own indecisiveness, but he prompts the audience, too, searching for their support: “Am I a coward?” he asks. His questions break the fourth wall, looking for answers in the audience.

Sometimes they talk back: from an intoxicated spectator at the Royal Shakespeare Company in the 1960s who shouted “yes!” to a teenager at the Stratford Festival in 2022 who whispered “no,” audiences want to speak with Hamlet, responding to his self-doubt with their own perspectives.

Hamlet knew about the theatre’s liberating power, too. In his search for a public voice, he chose to stage a play to expose corruption in Denmark. “The play’s the thing,” he said, “wherein I’ll catch the conscience of the king.”

Psychology researchers agree. Attending a play is proven to provoke the awakening of conscience, helping audiences empathize with political views that differ from their own. This understanding leads to pro-social behaviour outside the theatre.

Empathy, insight and social engagement

After watching a play by American playwright Dominique Morisseau about the impacts of the 2008 auto plant closures in Detroit, audiences were more likely to donate to and volunteer with charities supporting the homeless.

Seeing the vulnerability of fellow human beings onstage helps audience members become more empathetic towards each others’ experiences.

Theatre also helps the artists who make it rediscover their humanity. In the 2013 book Shakespeare Saved My Life, English professor Laura Bates writes about her experience teaching “the bard” to men in solitary confinement who could only speak to each other through slots in their cell doors.

One incarcerated person found a kindred spirit in Richard II, who is imprisoned at the end of his play. Reading Macbeth helped him understand the mistakes he made in his search for power.

A woman in a similar program in Michigan saw herself in Lady Anne’s grief in Richard III. Beyond empathizing with the characters, prisoners also felt empowered to confront the roles they had played in their past and to imagine new roles for the future.

Building community

The path towards empowerment or freedom through theatre is not limited to incarcerated spaces or grand professional stages.

Liberating theatre can take place wherever people gather: in living rooms and community centres; in parks and church basements; in a drama classroom or even on Zoom, where people can read plays aloud, improvise scenes from their own lives and create new stories together.

These modest theatrical gatherings offer something our devices cannot: the experience of being present with others in shared creative work.

When we step into the roles of characters, we step outside the algorithmic predictions that have come to direct or define us online.

When we collaborate to tell a story, we build the kind of community that allows us to bear witness for each other. Hamlet ends with the Danish prince asking his friend, Horatio, to tell the truth about what has happened: “In this harsh world draw thy breath in pain to tell my story.”

The theatre’s liberating power belongs to anyone willing to gather with others, turn off their phones and tell stories.

Each small theatrical gathering becomes an act of resistance — a reclaiming of our capacity for connection and conversation.

The Conversation

Marie Trotter receives funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.

Paul Yachnin receives funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.

ref. How Shakespeare can help us overcome loneliness in the digital age – https://theconversation.com/how-shakespeare-can-help-us-overcome-loneliness-in-the-digital-age-259628

Censoring video games with sexual content suppresses the diversity of human desire

Source: The Conversation – Canada – By Jean Ketterling, Assistant Professor, Political Studies – Women’s and Gender Studies Program, University of Saskatchewan

The battle over adult content is provoking concern about censorship and threatening game makers’ livelihoods. (Pexels/John Petalcurin)

Following a campaign by Australian anti-porn organization Collective Shout, the video game distribution platforms Steam and itch.io recently made changes to their policies about hosting games with adult themes.

While Steam removed many games, the campaign has had a particularly strong effect on itch.io because it is a smaller company with low barriers for creators who want to publish their games. The changes meant all content deemed adult NSFW (not suitable for work) on itch.io was unsearchable.

The campaign has also involved pressuring payment processing companies to “cease processing payments” to platforms hosting games that Collective Shout views as objectionable.

Itch.io has since announced it will be re-indexing free adult NSFW content, making it searchable again, and is “actively reaching out to other payment processors that are more willing to work with this kind of content.”

The battle over NSFW content is provoking concern about censorship and threatening game makers’ livelihoods. As game studies scholars who focus on sex, sexuality, gender and sexual violence, we are concerned about censorship campaigns that target pornography, and the knock-on effects on queer creators and sexual education content.




Read more:
Thousands of games have been censored from major platforms, with LGBTQIA+ creators caught in the crossfire


What happened to NSFW content on itch.io and Steam?

According to a timeline published by Collective Shout, the campaign began in March 2025 as an effort to have the controversial game No Mercy removed from Steam. While the developer removed the game in April, Collective Shout then called on payment processors to stop processing payments for similar content.

The campaign is less interested in the content or context of these games than achieving the organization’s broader anti-pornography goals.

As journalist Emanuel Maiberg writes, while No Mercy may aim to shock, it retreads many commonplace pornographic tropes, and Steam offers users tools to filter out adult content.

Nonetheless, bringing such games to payment processors’ attention set off a chain reaction and provoked heightened scrutiny on a wide range of sexual content.

On July 16, the third-party data website Steam DB posted that Steam had updated its content policy and removed many games that appeared to have incest themes.

On July 24, itch.io released a statement explaining that it had de-indexed all adult NSFW content while it conducted a “comprehensive audit of content” to ensure that the platform “can meet the requirements of our payment processors.”

De-indexing content makes it impossible to find via a browser search (although it remains available through a direct link), provoking concern about censorship and loss of livelihood.

A counter-campaign to protest censorship also emerged and various industry groups responded.

Platform policies and pornography

Feminist movements have a long history of debating pornography, and nuanced research is readily available that carefully analyzes pornography, including in a dedicated academic journal. Similarly, there is a growing body of research on sex and sexuality in video games.

Anti-pornography movements, however, do not seem to be informed by these discussions and debates. Rather, campaigns like Collective Shout’s rely on feelings of discomfort, disgust and shock to bring about broad censorship.

This can undermine the diversity of sexual expression, punishes non-normative and kinky content and disproportionately affects LGBTQ+ creators.

Steam’s updated policy states that developers should not use their platform to publish content that violates payment processor or card network policy, “in particular, certain kinds of adult only content.”

Itch.io clarified its existing policy by providing a list of content prohibited by payment processors, including real or implied non-consensual content, underage or “barely legal” themes, incest or pseudo-incest content, bestiality or animal-related content and fetish content involving bodily waste or extreme harm, among others.

Such prohibitions may feel like common sense. However, there is a danger these provisions could be used to de-platform broad swaths of content. This could include games made by survivors of sexual violence or child abuse reflecting on their experiences, or consent education games such as Hurt Me Plenty.

Research has shown similar policies on porn platforms are interpreted so broadly that they de-platform otherwise legal content. When implemented, these policies impact creators’ abilities to earn a living.

An animated man on his hands an knees. He is wearing white underwear. A pink outline of a hand is slapping his butt. Blue and green emojis indicate the man's feelings.
A screenshot from ‘Hurt Me Plenty,’ developer Robert Yang’s educational game about BDSM and consent.
(Robert Yang)

De-platforming sex in games

Video game censorship is not new. American game developer Brenda Romero describes the creation of the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB) in 1994 as the industry’s attempt to self-regulate after several controversies regarding violent and sexual content.

The ESRB was created by the Entertainment Software Association to assign age ratings to games in North America. While creating the ESRB helped stave off governmental regulation, it did so by curtailing the space for sexual expression in games.

Video games with explicit sexual content are likely to receive an adults only rating and large box chain retailers may refuse to stock them.

To be economically viable, game developers are forced to remove references to sexual activity from their games, as was the case with the infamous “hot coffee” modification in Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas.

This type of self-censorship is a problem that extends beyond games. According to feminist media scholar Susanna Paasonen, platforms often conceptualize sex as risky, objectionable and lacking expressive value, imposing their subjective understanding of obscenity and risk on culturally diverse audiences.

Many arguments for censorship rely on an assumption that games predominately have an audience of children. However, the average American gamer is 36 years old, and removing access to diverse sexual content for adults is to deny an entire realm of human experience.

Thus, the “de-sexing” of platforms is a problem in and of itself.

Payment processors dictating content

Collective Shout’s appeal to payment processors is a strategy that exploits the power these companies have, because payment processors and credit card networks have significant influence on the sex industry. By refusing to process payments for certain products or services, they have the power to effectively censor anything they deem unnacceptable.

The process leaves little room for transparency around what qualifies as unacceptable, and can leave those impacted by such bans with limited ability to challenge them.

Given that payment processors focus more on protecting their brand reputation than promoting a diversity of sexual expression, they are vulnerable to the agendas of outspoken organizations that use them as a backdoor to police sexual expression.

As researchers, we are equally concerned with the ways these policies threaten the preservation of video games. Despite their long history, sex and pornography games are a neglected archive.

It is imperative to build and sustain public game archives that can withstand such targeted attacks and preserve the record of human desire from multiple perspectives.

The Conversation

Jean Ketterling is the principal investigator of The Pornography, Platforms & Play Project, which is supported in part by funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. She is the vice-president of the Canadian Game Studies Association.

Ashley ML Guajardo is president of the Digital Games Research Association.

Carl Therrien and Kenzie Gordon do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

ref. Censoring video games with sexual content suppresses the diversity of human desire – https://theconversation.com/censoring-video-games-with-sexual-content-suppresses-the-diversity-of-human-desire-262436

Israel’s opposition: against Benjamin Netanyahu but not yet for peace with the Palestinians

Source: The Conversation – UK – By John Strawson, Emeritus Professor of Law, University of East London

Sunday is the first day of the working week in Israel – but the upcoming Sunday August 17 promises to be a day of strikes and demonstrations. There’s a groundswell of public opposition to prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s promised all-out offensive against Gaza city as well as a growing sense of desperation at the plight of the remaining hostages.

The question is how will these actions on the streets translate into a coherent political alternative to Netanyahu in Knesset elections? The next election must take place by October 2026 – but it might well happen sooner.

Netanyahu has presided over the most right-wing government in the country’s history. During his current term from October 2022, mass protests have been a feature of Israeli society. Initially they were against the government’s attack on the powers of the supreme court, which many saw as a more general attack on democracy.

Now, with the failure of the military operation in Gaza to secure the release of all the October 7 hostages, the need to secure a ceasefire or a more permanent end to the war to bring the hostages home has become the focus of public protests. August 17 is likely to involve the largest national mobilisation yet.

But despite the mass action on the streets, Israel’s opposition parties have remained divided on policy and largely united only in their dislike of Netanyahu. Only the left: the Labor Party and Meretz seem to have grasped that the time has come to offer the country a clear political alternative.

After decades of rivalry, they’ve merged into one party, the Democrats, under the leadership of charismatic former deputy chief of staff of the Israel Defense Forces, Yair Golan.

Yesh Atid (which translates as There is a Future) led by Yair Lapid offer a broadly centrist political platforms. Like the Democrats, Yesh Atid has been active in the campaign for securing the release of the hostages but is largely silent on any resolution of the conflict with the Palestinians.

The rest of the opposition: Benny Gantz’s Blue and White and Avigdor Leiberman’s Yisrael Beitenu are firmly on the centre-right. Gantz’s party places security as its main policy but has been open to compromise with Netanyahu on the judicial reforms. Leiberman’s party is rooted among Russian immigrants and maintains a nationalist position. Once a Netanyahu associate, he is now a major critic.

Israel’s electoral system requires parties to work together to forge coalitions. Netanyahu did so in November 2022 with the support of the most right-wing parties in the Knesset. Now the polls are predicting that it is Naftali Bennet, who served as prime minister from June 2021 to June 2022, who is shaping up as the most likely candidate to lead the opposition bloc into the next election.

Bennett led a broad coalition which briefly interrupted Netanyahu’s second period in office. Consequentially, his government was supported by Mansour Abbas’s Ra’am, or United Arab List. Abbas’s presence in the coalition underlines the significance of the role that Arab parties potentially play in Israeli politics, representing, as they do, 20% of Israel’s population in a system where lawmakers are chosen by proportional representations.

But Israel’s Arab parties, which range across different shades of Islamism, Arab nationalism and socialism, are as factionalised and divided as the Jewish parties.

What the public want

A lot will depend on how the parties handle the war and hostage questions. Opinion polls consistently show there is a large majority of Israelis (74%) in favour of ending the war in Gaza and bringing the hostages home.

A majority of people, 55%, now think that Netanyahu is handling the war badly . This level of approval, together with mass action on Israel’s streets, presents an opportunity for Israel’s opposition parties to paint themselves as a viable alternative government.

Now, nearly two years after the October 7 attack, with the unresolved hostage situation, mounting settler violence on the West Bank and Israel becoming ever more isolated internationally, this issue has become even more acute. People want the war to end.

But this doesn’t translate into support for a two-state solution, which has fallen since October 7 to a small minority of 21% of voters.

It’s not what will bring people on to the streets on August 17. During the last major period of public unrest – the pro-democracy protests of two years ago – the organisers of the marches actively discouraged comparisons between the attack on democracy in Israel and the decidedly undemocratic Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza.

While today there are groups such as Jewish-Arab Standing Together who make that case, especially after the course of the Gaza war, these forces are far from the mainstream of even the most activist opponents against Netanyahu’s war.

Sunday’s demonstrations will be a significant moment for Israel and a real challenge to Netanyahu’s government. It is possible that in the next few months his government will fall over the withdrawal of the ultra-orthodox parties who are angry about the goverment’s decision to revoke the exemption for ultra-orthodox Jews from the armed forces.

This is likely to make passing a budget problematic and may well trigger an elections much earlier than scheduled. Netanyahu could well face an electorate exhausted by the trauma of October 7, wars on many fronts and rising Israeli casualties in Gaza.

If the opinion polls are right, and an anti-Netanyahu bloc wins a majority, there could even be a new government in the next six months.

But to dismiss a more permanent settlement with Palestine cannot be viable in the long term. Any government committed to defending Israeli democracy will find that it is incompatible with continuing denial of Palestinian democracy. Unless there is peace with its Palestinian neighbours, Israel will not be at peace with itself.

The Conversation

John Strawson does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

ref. Israel’s opposition: against Benjamin Netanyahu but not yet for peace with the Palestinians – https://theconversation.com/israels-opposition-against-benjamin-netanyahu-but-not-yet-for-peace-with-the-palestinians-262975

Ancient Incans of all classes used coded strings of hair for record keeping – new research

Source: The Conversation – UK – By Sabine Hyland, Professor of Social Anthropology, University of St Andrews

The author studying a khipu. Author provided, CC BY-SA

The people of the ancient Incan empire kept careful records of their economics, religion, demographics and history. Those records took the form of knotted cords called khipus.

Until now, researchers believed that the only people who knew how to make khipus in the Inca empire (circa 1400-1532) were very elite, high-status officials. With little direct evidence about the Inca khipu experts, researchers like myself have relied on descriptions by colonial Spanish chroniclers.

According to written sources, khipus were made exclusively by high-ranking bureaucrats who enjoyed the finest food and drink. In the Inca tradition, there was no distinction between “author” and “scribe”; both roles were combined into one.

The term used to describe an Inca khipu maker, “khipu kamayuq”, derives from the verb “kamay” which refers to creation in the sense of energising matter. Khipu experts – “kamayuq” – energised the khipus they made by imbuing the cords with their own vitality.

I head a team of researchers that has uncovered new evidence that commoners also made khipus in the Inca empire, meaning khipu literacy may have been more inclusive than previously thought. The key to this discovery is the realisation that khipu experts sometimes “signed” the khipus they made with locks of their own hair.

In Inca cosmology, human hair carried a person’s essence. A person’s hair retained his or her identity even when it was physically separated from the body. A child’s first hair-cutting, for example, was a major rite of passage. The hair removed in this ritual was given as an offering to the gods or kept in the house as a sacred object.

The Inca emperor’s hair clippings were saved during his lifetime; after death his hair was fashioned into a life-size simulacrum that was worshipped as the emperor himself.




Read more:
The Inca string code that reveals Peru’s climate history


Historically, when human hair was tied onto khipus, the hair was the “signature” of the person from whom the hair was removed. Our team observed this recently in the highland village of Jucul in Peru, where villagers possess over 90 ancestral khipus, some made centuries ago.

On the khipus of Jucul, human hair attached to the primary cord represents the people who made each section of the khipu. This accords with earlier findings that herders in highland Peru tied their own hair to khipus “like a signature”, signifying their responsibility for the information on the cords.

Personal objects tied to or otherwise incorporated into the primary cord represent the khipu creator or author. For example, on a 16th-century khipu from the Andean community of Collata, strips of a leader’s insignia scarf tied to the primary cord symbolise the man who authored the khipu, imbuing the khipu with his authority.

In contrast, when khipus contained information about multiple people, each person’s data was signified by a band of pendants of the same colour or by including hair from multiple people in the pendants.

Analysing the hair

Our team identified an Inca-era khipu, known as KH0631, with a primary cord made entirely of human hair from a single person. Until now, khipus have not been examined for the presence of human hair, so it is unknown how often they contain hair.

The human hair in KH0631’s primary cord likely represented the person who made the khipu, marking the khipu with this person’s authority and essence.

The hair in the KH0631 primary cord, 104cm long, was folded in half and twisted when the khipu was made. Assuming hair growth at 1cm per month, the hair represents over eight years of growth.

To learn about the person who made the khipu, we undertook simultaneous carbon, nitrogen and sulphur isotope measurements from a sample at the end of the cord.

The presence of the C4 isotope (instead of C3) generally indicates the consumption of maize in Andean diets; the relative levels of stable nitrogen isotopes allow us to make inferences about the proportion of meat in the diet; and the levels of stable sulphur isotopes enables us to determine the amount of marine food sources.

Because the hair was doubled over, the loose end included hair cut nearest the scalp and hair from the end of the tresses. This meant the sample represented two periods of the person’s life separated by eight or more years.

Isotopic analysis of carbon, nitrogen and sulphur in human hair has been used to determine the diet of ancient Andeans. The diet of high-status versus low-status groups in the Inca state differed greatly.

A woman looking over a glass exhibit case
The author in the Pitt Rivers Museum, Oxford undertaking research.
Author provided, CC BY-SA

Elite people consumed more meat and maize-based dishes, while commoners ate more tubers, like potatoes and greens. To our surprise, isotopic analysis of the human hair in KH0631 revealed that this person had the diet of a low-status commoner, eating a plant-based diet of tubers and greens with very little meat or maize.

Sulphur isotope analysis shows little marine contribution to the diet, indicating that this person probably lived in the highlands rather than the coast. In the ancient Andes, elites feasted on meat and maize beer, while commoners dined on potatoes, legumes and pseudo-grains like quinoa. It appears that the khipu expert who made KH0631 was a commoner.

We don’t know where in the Andes KH0631 was made, so we tested the oxygen and hydrogen isotopes in the sample. Our results show that the person lived in the highlands between 2,600-2,800m above sea level in southern Peru or northern Chile (without better data on local water values, the exact location remains tentative).

This is the first time that isotopic analysis has been conducted on khipu fibres. The human hair “signature” in KH0631’s primary cord allowed us to learn more about the person who made this object.

Although other researchers have argued that only elite officials made khipus in the Inca empire, our new evidence suggests that commoners made khipus too – and that khipu literacy may have been more widespread than previously believed.


Looking for something good? Cut through the noise with a carefully curated selection of the latest releases, live events and exhibitions, straight to your inbox every fortnight, on Fridays. Sign up here.


The Conversation

Sabine Hyland receives funding from the John Simon Guggenheim Foundation, the British Academy, the Leverhulme Trust, the British Museum and the University of St Andrews Impact Fund.

ref. Ancient Incans of all classes used coded strings of hair for record keeping – new research – https://theconversation.com/ancient-incans-of-all-classes-used-coded-strings-of-hair-for-record-keeping-new-research-263063

Les professionnels de la santé ne sont pas à l’abri des préjugés envers les personnes handicapées

Source: The Conversation – in French – By Matthieu P. Boisgontier, Professor, Faculty of Health Sciences, L’Université d’Ottawa/University of Ottawa

Puisque les attitudes des praticiens de santé peuvent influencer les soins prodigués aux personnes en situation de handicap, intensifier les efforts pour améliorer ces attitudes devrait être une priorité des institutions de formation et des politiques de santé. (Shutterstock)

Nous avons tous des biais, qu’ils soient positifs ou négatifs, lorsque nous analysons les situations et les personnes qui nous entourent.

Par exemple, on peut spontanément penser, à tort, qu’une personne qui parle avec un accent est moins compétente, que les garçons sont naturellement meilleurs en mathématiques, ou encore qu’une personne avec un handicap physique a forcément des difficultés intellectuelles et qu’elle ne peut donc pas occuper un poste à responsabilités.

Qu’on le veuille ou non, ces biais psychologiques, aussi appelés attitudes, sont incrustés dans notre cerveau et influencent tant nos décisions que nos comportements au quotidien.

Les cliniciens ne sont pas à l’abri d’attitudes défavorables, notamment à l’égard de leurs patients.

Chercheur en neuropsychologie de la santé à l’Université d’Ottawa, je propose d’apporter un éclairage sur deux études que j’ai menées sur les attitudes envers les personnes en situation de handicap.

Testez vos propres biais en quelques clics !

Mes deux études se basent sur les données de participants répartis en trois grands groupes professionnels : les cliniciens (médecins, physiothérapeutes, ergothérapeutes, infirmiers), les assistants en réadaptation (notamment les aides-ergothérapeutes et aides-physiothérapeutes) et les personnes exerçant d’autres professions, pas forcément en relation avec la santé.

Ces données ont été recueillies pendant 19 ans sur le site Implicit Project, qui offre à n’importe qui, n’importe où dans le monde, la possibilité de tester gratuitement et anonymement ses attitudes dans différents domaines, tels que l’origine ethnique, la religion, le poids, la sexualité et le handicap.

Personnes handicapées ou personnes en situation de handicap ?

Avant de présenter mes deux études plus en détail, je dois préciser que mon choix de mots pour parler du handicap n’est pas dû au hasard.

L’expression « personne en situation de handicap » est parfois privilégiée, car elle met l’accent sur la personne plutôt que sur le handicap. À l’inverse, l’expression « personne handicapée » peut être perçue comme une réduction de la personne à son handicap.

Cependant, des recherches récentes montrent que l’utilisation du terme « personne en situation de handicap » ne réduit pas toujours les préjugés, et pourrait même renforcer la distance ou la condescendance.

De plus, imposer un seul type de langage pourrait occulter les préférences de chacun.

L’Association américaine de psychologie conclut que les deux formulations sont légitimes, tant qu’elles sont utilisées avec bienveillance et qu’elles respectent les préférences des personnes concernées.

Attitudes implicites et attitudes explicites

La première étude, publiée dans Physiotherapy Canada, se base sur les données de plus de 660 000 participants.

Elle a permis de caractériser l’évolution des attitudes envers deux types de handicaps : le handicap général, incluant la cécité par exemple (données récoltées de 2006 à 2021), et le handicap physique (données récoltées de 2022 à 2024).

L’étude teste aussi deux types d’attitudes : les attitudes explicites, qui peuvent être formulées consciemment en répondant à des questionnaires (par exemple : « je préfère les personnes qui ne sont pas en situation de handicap aux personnes handicapées »), et les attitudes implicites (ou automatiques), qui sont souvent inconscientes.

Le test d’association implicite, qui est notamment utilisé sur le site Implicit Project, permet d’évaluer ces attitudes implicites. Son fonctionnement est simple. Les participants doivent classer le plus rapidement possible et sans se tromper des mots et des images en associant, par exemple, des concepts de « bon » ou « mauvais » à des images illustrant le handicap ou l’absence de handicap.

Il importe cependant de noter que ce test n’est pas sans limites. En effet, son association avec les comportements réels est faible, ce qui pousse certains chercheurs à recommander l’ajout de mesures physiologiques des attitudes, comme l’activité cérébrale, ainsi que d’entretiens qui permettent de mieux comprendre les perceptions et les expériences des individus.

Un discours qui évolue, des automatismes qui persistent

Les résultats montrent que les attitudes explicites – soit celles qui sont déclarées par les participants – à l’égard des personnes handicapées sont devenues moins défavorables au fil des années.

Cependant, les attitudes implicites (inconscientes) sont restées relativement stables et défavorables.

En effet, pendant la période de l’étude, la population générale, incluant les cliniciens, semble avoir plus de difficulté à associer des images illustrant le handicap à des mots positifs qu’à des mots négatifs, en comparaison à des images illustrant l’absence de handicap.

Ces attitudes défavorables sont particulièrement marquées lorsqu’il s’agit de handicap physique, tel que représenté par des personnes en fauteuil roulant ou des personnes qui utilisent des béquilles ou une canne.

En comparaison, les attitudes semblaient légèrement moins négatives envers des formes de handicap plus générales, incluant par exemple des personnes aveugles et malvoyantes.

Les professionnels de la santé pas épargnés

La seconde étude, publiée dans European Rehabilitation Journal, s’est concentrée sur les données des années 2022 à 2024 portant uniquement sur le handicap physique et incluant plus de 210 000 personnes.

Les résultats renforcent l’idée d’une préférence implicite et explicite de l’ensemble de la population pour les personnes sans handicap, tout en montrant que les cliniciens ne sont pas mieux prédisposés que les autres professions.

Il semble donc que la profession ait peu d’effets sur les attitudes envers les personnes handicapées.

Cependant, d’autres facteurs ont émergé des analyses. D’une part, les hommes ont des attitudes plus défavorables envers les personnes handicapées que les femmes. D’autre part, les participants ayant une expérience personnelle du handicap, comme avoir des amis, des connaissances ou des membres de la famille handicapés, ou qui sont eux-mêmes handicapés, ont des attitudes plus favorables envers les personnes handicapées.

Un impact sur les soins de santé ?

La présence et la stabilité d’attitudes implicites défavorables chez les cliniciens soulèvent des questions quant à leur possible impact sur les soins prodigués aux patients.

En particulier, la première étude a montré que les attitudes étaient plus défavorables envers les personnes en situation de handicap physique qu’envers les personnes ayant d’autres types de handicaps, comme la cécité, potentiellement parce que ces derniers sont moins évidents.

Est-ce que cette différence d’attitudes pourrait rendre leur prise en charge moins équitable ? Ce n’est pas impossible. En effet, les attitudes, en plus de prédire les comportements futurs, influencent la prise de décision dans des contextes professionnels.

Par exemple, un clinicien ayant un biais implicite défavorable pourrait, sans s’en rendre compte, consacrer moins de temps à un patient en fauteuil roulant, douter de sa capacité à suivre un traitement, ou encore orienter ce patient vers des options moins ambitieuses de réadaptation.

De même, il pourrait accorder plus de crédibilité aux plaintes ou objectifs de santé d’un patient non handicapé qu’à ceux d’un patient ayant une limitation physique visible. Ces décisions, bien qu’anodines en apparence, peuvent en s’accumulant aboutir à des inégalités d’accès, de qualité ou d’expérience des soins.

professionnelle de la santé avec un patient en chaise roulante dans un corridor d’hôpital
Un clinicien ayant un biais implicite défavorable pourrait par exemple, sans s’en rendre compte, consacrer moins de temps à un patient en fauteuil roulant, douter de sa capacité à suivre un traitement, ou encore orienter ce patient vers des options moins ambitieuses de réadaptation.
(Shutterstock)

Le poids du capacitisme

Ces résultats illustrent la tendance de nos sociétés à considérer une personne handicapée comme intrinsèquement moins capable ou moins importante que les personnes qui ne sont pas en situation de handicap.

Cette dévalorisation des personnes en situation de handicap s’appelle le « capacitisme ». Tout comme le racisme, le sexisme et l’âgisme, le capacitisme ostracise une partie de la société en réduisant, consciemment ou inconsciemment, leurs opportunités de participer à la vie de leurs collectivités.

Historiquement, le handicap a longtemps été perçu comme une anomalie à corriger pour correspondre aux normes de la société.

Si de nos jours, les modèles de référence ont dépassé cette vision réductrice du handicap, mes résultats suggèrent que le capacitisme continue d’imprégner notre société, de façon systémique et culturelle, influençant jusqu’à nos professionnels de la santé.

Comment réduire ces biais ?

Même si nos attitudes déclarées envers les personnes en situation de handicap se sont améliorées au fil des années, nos préjugés inconscients persistent.

Ce constat souligne l’importance de mettre en place des stratégies éducatives plus efficaces.

Les interventions les plus prometteuses sont celles qui vont au-delà de la simple transmission d’informations en ajoutant des rencontres et des expériences, directes ou indirectes, avec des personnes handicapées. Cette exposition favorise l’empathie.

Pour déconstruire les stéréotypes de façon durable, il faut multiplier ces occasions de côtoyer des personnes handicapées.

Puisque les attitudes des praticiens de santé peuvent influencer les soins prodigués aux personnes en situation de handicap, intensifier les efforts pour améliorer ces attitudes devrait être une priorité des institutions de formation et des politiques de santé.

À une époque où les idéaux d’équité sont à la fois en progrès et en danger, la lutte contre ces tendances psychologiques défavorables aux personnes handicapées est non seulement essentielle pour améliorer leurs soins, mais aussi une priorité éthique pour la société que nous voulons construire pour notre futur.

La Conversation Canada

Dr. Matthieu P. Boisgontier est professeur à la Faculté des sciences de la santé et directeur de l’Ecole des sciences de la réadaptation de l’Université d’Ottawa, au Canada. Il est chercheur senior à l’Institut du Savoir Monfort et au Bruyère Health Research Institute d’Ottawa. Il est le manager principal de Peer Community In (PCI) Health & Movement Sciences. Il est également rédacteur en chef du journal Communications in Kinesiology et membre de la Society for Transparency, Openness, and Replication in Kinesiology (STORK).

ref. Les professionnels de la santé ne sont pas à l’abri des préjugés envers les personnes handicapées – https://theconversation.com/les-professionnels-de-la-sante-ne-sont-pas-a-labri-des-prejuges-envers-les-personnes-handicapees-252847

Seguimos sin invertir lo suficiente en prevención de incendios

Source: The Conversation – (in Spanish) – By Víctor Resco de Dios, Catedrático de Ingeniería Forestal y Cambio Global, Universitat de Lleida

Los incendios forestales han vuelto, un estío más, a copar los titulares informativos en España con un importante número de focos en las comunidades de Galicia, Castilla y León y Extremadura.

Tal vez el fuego pueda parecer la consecuencia inexorable de vivir en entornos mediterráneos o atlánticos, que son zonas con mucha vegetación y una larga sequía estival. Pero ¿es esto realmente así? ¿Podríamos haber evitado por lo menos parte del daño que están infligiendo las llamas?

Extinción vs. prevención

La respuesta al problema de los incendios forestales se ha centrado en fortalecer la extinción, pero responder a un problema no es lo mismo que solucionarlo. Responder es hacer algo, cualquier cosa, independientemente de su efectividad o eficacia. Solucionar un problema, sin embargo, implica abordar las causas estructurales con el fin de evitar aquellos daños que sean evitables y de aprovechar las oportunidades que nos pueda brindar la eventualidad.

Aumentar los recursos para la extinción es una medida populista, que goza de aceptación popular, pero que no soluciona el problema. Algunas estimaciones indican que el 75 % de las descargas aéreas, por poner un ejemplo, son inútiles.

¿Cómo solucionamos el problema, entonces? La clave yace en pasar de apagar incendios a gestionar el fuego.

¿En qué consiste gestionar el fuego?

Para entender cómo gestionar el fuego, debemos antes comprender su papel ecológico y social. El fuego, junto con los herbívoros y algunos microbios, se encarga de reciclar la biomasa en los ecosistemas. Esto es, las plantas crecen continuamente, pero la biomasa no se acumula indefinidamente porque los incendios la queman, las herbívoros la comen y los microbios la descomponen.

Muchos de nuestros ecosistemas tienen ahora una carga de biomasa que ya no es natural. Tras el abandono rural, la actividad de los herbívoros ha pasado a ser anecdótica, dejando a los incendios como el principal encargado de reciclar ese exceso de biomasa. Los incendios actuales son particularmente voraces porque se encuentran con unas acumulaciones de combustible exageradas.




Leer más:
Más herbívoros salvajes para prevenir los incendios


Gestionar el fuego, por tanto, no quiere decir únicamente apagar las llamas tan pronto como salta la primera chispa. Gestionar el fuego consiste, ante todo, en gestionar ese exceso de biomasa, de manera que entendamos el papel ecosistémico del fuego y que lo aprovechemos a nuestro favor.

En algunos casos, la gestión del fuego implicará que podamos dejar que algunos incendios ardan, siempre que se pueda garantizar la seguridad. También debemos introducir el fuego a través de quemas prescritas, que consumen la biomasa de forma segura para la población, a la par que contribuyen al reciclaje de nutrientes.

Otras medidas incluyen favorecer la ganadería extensiva, que disminuya el combustible, reducir la espesura de los bosques, que se encuentran en los niveles más altos de los últimos 100 000 años, y fortalecer la actividad agrícola.

Los incendios como problema político

Aunque actualmente se llevan a cabo algunas estrategias para la prevención de incendios en España, estas son escasas y no de la magnitud necesaria. Las competencias están actualmente transferidas a las comunidades autónomas.

En contra de lo que se considera tradicionalmente, la principal limitación a la gestión del fuego y a la prevención no es pecuniaria. Desde el Grupo de Refuerzo de Actuaciones Forestales de Bombers de Catalunya han estimado que la extinción cuesta unas 19 000 €/ha, mientras que la prevención se sitúa en los 3 000 €/ha cuando hablamos de claras (cortar árboles) o desbroces, o en los 300 €/ha en el caso de las quemas prescritas.

Tampoco se trata de una limitación científica, ya que los estudios existentes apuntan a cómo abordar el problema. Y desde el punto de vista técnico, ingenieril, también sabemos qué debemos hacer. Se trata, principalmente, de un problema político. Porque para abordar plenamente la gestión del fuego y de los ecosistemas se necesitan políticos valientes.

En la cabeza de muchos legisladores planean ideas románticas sobre la naturaleza, que confunden ecologismo con edenismo. Esto es, se pretende proteger a la naturaleza anulando la intervención humana, o llevándola a su mínima expresión. El caso más acusado lo encontramos en las áreas protegidas, que actualmente se queman de forma desproporcionada.

El fuego en las áreas protegidas

Los incendios en Las Médulas (León) o Tres Cantos (Madrid), por ejemplo, ocurrieron en zonas protegidas. Las estadísticas revelan que estas áreas pueden llegar a arder hasta 17 puntos por encima de lo que les correspondería. Además, la severidad del incendio, o su intensidad, es un 20 % mayor que en los bosques no protegidos y la exposición de la población que vive en estos espacios, o en su periferia, es un 900 % mayor.

Las causas las encontramos en las grandes acumulaciones de biomasa resultantes de la escasa actividad forestal, junto con el bajo número de accesos y factores topográficos y meteorológicos.

Fuera de las áreas protegidas también nos encontramos con problemas serios. El agricultor que pretenda recuperar tierras abandonadas hace unas décadas para su cultivo, por poner un ejemplo, se topará con una legislación que le obligará a realizar una evaluación de impacto ambiental incluso si solo pretende recuperar una hectárea de terreno. Esto supone un coste muy elevado y desincentivará la inversión, y la ley de deforestación que está preparando la Comisión Europea podría agravar aún más la situación.

Recordemos que llamamos hogar a nuestra casa. Hogar viene de hoguera, de estar cerca del fuego, socializando y cocinando. Debemos recuperar la gestión del fuego para vivir tranquilos en nuestros hogares.

The Conversation

Víctor Resco de Dios recibe fondos de de MICINN y la Comisión Europea.

ref. Seguimos sin invertir lo suficiente en prevención de incendios – https://theconversation.com/seguimos-sin-invertir-lo-suficiente-en-prevencion-de-incendios-263155